Best Homemade Tomato Pie Recipe

Last August, Lina helped me harvest our first serious Tomato Pie crop and asked what we’d do with “all these tomatoes.” That’s when I pulled out my grandmother’s handwritten recipe card for her famous summer tomato pie. Lina was skeptical at first – “pie made of tomatoes sounds weird, Mom” – but after one bite, she was hooked. Now she helps me make it every time our tomatoes are ready, and it’s become our end-of-summer tradition.

Why You’ll Love This Southern Tomato Pie

Lina was doubtful the first time we made this together. “It’s like pizza but backwards,” she said, watching me layer sliced tomatoes instead of sauce. But after that first bite – the way the juicy tomatoes meld with creamy cheese and flaky crust – she was hooked. Now every August, she asks when we’re making “the backwards pizza” again.

What makes this recipe special is how it handles the biggest challenge with tomato pie: preventing a soggy bottom. The secret lies in salting the tomatoes beforehand and choosing the right combination of cheeses. It’s not fussy or complicated, just good technique that lets those beautiful summer tomatoes shine. Plus, it’s one of those dishes that tastes even better the next day, making it perfect for potlucks or make-ahead dinners.

Ingredients for Classic Tomato Pie Recipe

What You Need:

• Ripe tomatoes
• Pie crust
• Coarse salt for draining
• Fresh basil
• Sharp cheddar cheese
• Mozzarella cheese
• Mayonnaise
• Dijon mustard

Extra Good Stuff:

• Sweet onion if you want
• Fresh thyme
• Garlic powder
• Black pepper
• Parmesan cheese

See recipe card for quantities.

How To Make Tomato Pie Step By Step

Start Here:

• Wait 30 minutes while you do other stuff
• Slice tomatoes thick as your thumb
• Put them on paper towels
• Salt both sides good

Fix Your Crust:

• Bake the empty crust at 375°F for 10 minutes
• Stab it with a fork so it stays flat
• Let it cool down

Mix the Gooey Stuff:

• Dump mayo and mustard in a bowl
• Throw in the shredded cheeses
• Add garlic powder and pepper
• Stir until it’s all mixed up

Stack It Up:

• Dry off those tomato slices real good
• Put half in the crust
• Rip up some basil and scatter it around
• Spread that cheese goop on top
• Add the rest of the tomatoes
• More basil and cheese if you want

Cook It:

• Don’t cut it right away or it’ll be a mess
• 350°F for about 30 minutes
• Should look golden and smell amazing

Smart Swaps for Your Tomato Pie

Tomato Swaps:

• No fresh ones → Good canned tomatoes, drain them really well
• Only small tomatoes → Cut them in half, still salt them
• Green tomatoes → Slice them thin, let them sit longer
• Whatever’s on sale → Just make sure they’re not squishy

Crust Changes:

• No pie crust → Puff pastry from the freezer works
• Need gluten-free → Store brands are fine
• Want homemade → Do it if you have time
• Skip the crust → Grease the pan, still tastes good

Cheese Mix-ups:

• No cheddar → Any sharp cheese works
• Can’t do dairy → Those fake cheeses melt okay
• Trying to be healthy → Low-fat cheese tastes different but works
• Feeling fancy → Gruyere makes people think you’re a good cook

Other Switches:

• No basil → Oregano or just leave it out
• No mustard → Little bit of hot sauce
• No mayo → Sour cream does the job

Tomato Pie Recipe Variations

The Bacon One:

• Use the bacon grease on the crust edges
• Fry up some bacon until it’s crispy
• Crumble it between the tomato layers
• Lina says this beats all the others

With Onions:

• Slice a sweet onion really thin
• Put it in with the tomatoes
• Makes the kitchen smell so good
• Lina picks them out but I eat them

Different Herbs:

• Try stuff besides basil
• Thyme is really good
• Fresh chives work too
• Whatever’s growing outside

More Cheese:

• Throw in some goat cheese
• Feta makes it taste different
• Parmesan on top gets brown and crispy
• Use whatever’s in the fridge

Garden Veggies:

• Add thin zucchini slices
• Yellow squash is good too
• Still salt everything first
• Takes a bit longer to cook

Make It Spicy:

• Throw in some jalapeño slices
• Put hot sauce in the cheese mix
• Sprinkle red pepper flakes on top
• Lina won’t eat the spicy ones

Equipment For Tomato Pie Recipe

• Mixing bowl for the cheese stuff
• 9-inch pie pan
• Sharp knife for slicing tomatoes
• Cutting board
• Colander or big strainer
• Paper towels

Storage

Right After You Make It:

• Let it sit until it’s not hot anymore
• Don’t cover it while it’s still warm or it gets gross
• Takes about an hour to cool down

Keeping It Fresh:

• Wrap it up with plastic wrap or foil
• Sits in the fridge for 3-4 days
• Tastes better the next day anyway
• Lina always grabs cold pieces for breakfast

Heating It Up Again:

• Oven at 300°F for maybe 15 minutes
• Don’t microwave it – turns it into mush
• Cold pieces taste good too
• I eat it cold for lunch sometimes

Why This Tomato Pie Actually Works

After about fifty test runs half of them total flops I finally figured out the handful of steps that make this pie turn out right. There’s no magic secret, just a couple of steps you can’t skip. Salting and draining the tomatoes isn’t busywork; it keeps the filling from turning soupy. And mixing the mayo into the cheese before spreading it on makes the topping bake into a smooth layer instead of sliding around.

Lina always wonders why we can’t just toss everything in the pan and bake it. I gave that shortcut a try once, and the result was a disaster watery tomatoes, rubbery cheese, and a soggy bottom crust. This method works because each step solves a problem: pre-baking the crust keeps it crisp, draining the tomatoes stops the flood, and blending the topping helps it set. Nothing fancy just the simple fixes that make the whole thing hold together.

Top Tip

• Lina showed me something I never would have thought of while we were making tomato pie for her school event. She was getting restless waiting for the tomato slices to drain, asking me every few minutes, “Are they ready yet?” I finally told her to check, and she spotted what I’d been missing. “Mom, the bottoms are still wet,” she said, flipping a slice over.

• Since then, she insists we flip the tomato slices halfway through and sprinkle salt on both sides. And honestly, it makes a huge difference. The underside holds way more water than you’d ever expect, and if you don’t get it out, the pie ends up soggy no matter how long you wait for the tomatoes to drain.

• Lina proudly calls this trick “the flip thing,” and she’s now the official timekeeper every time we make tomato pie. She takes the job seriously, and I let her run with it. Thanks to her little discovery, my pies finally come out firm, rich, and never weighed down with water.

The Flavor My Best Friend Never Told Me About

For years, my friend’s tomato pie always tasted better than mine, no matter how closely I followed the recipe. Every summer I’d ask her what she did differently, and she’d just shrug and say, “Same as you.” I could taste something extra in hers but never figured it out. The mystery finally ended when my daughter Lina spent the night at her house and happened to watch her make it. She came home the next day practically bouncing with excitement: “Mom! She puts cream cheese in the mix!”

It turned out that my friend had always stirred a spoonful of cream cheese into the mayo-and-mustard mixture because that’s how her mom did it. She never thought it mattered enough to mention, but that small addition transforms the pie making it richer, creamier, and almost restaurant-level instead of plain home cooking. Now I do it too, and Lina always grins and reminds me not to forget “the special part.”

FAQ

Summer’s Best Tomato Pie Recipe Done Right!

Now you know the little details that turn tomato pie from “just okay” into something everyone asks for again and again. It isn’t about complicated steps or fancy tricks it’s about those small habits that make all the difference. Lina’s flip trick keeps the tomatoes from flooding everything, Sarah’s cream cheese addition makes the filling taste silky and rich, and the careful mixing of cheese and mayo ensures the top bakes up beautifully instead of sliding off. None of these steps are difficult, but together they create a pie that actually holds together and tastes incredible.

Want more recipes that use up garden stuff? Try our Delicious Turkey Cranberry Recipe that’s good for using up extra potatoes. Need lunch ideas? Our The Best Spinach Pie Recipe makes sandwiches that don’t suck. Got too much zucchini? Our Best Hearty Seafood Chowder Recipe turns them into dinner nobody whines about!

We’d love to see your tomato pie masterpieces. we can check them out.
Loved the recipe? Drop us a review and join our food‑loving crew!

Looking for other recipes like this? Try these:

Pairing

These are my favorite dishes to serve with  Tomato Pie

Tomato Pie

A Southern classic that turns fresh summer Tomato Pie into a creamy, cheesy, savory pie with a crisp crust. Passed down from Grandma’s handwritten card and perfected with Lina’s “flip trick,” this recipe is simple, rich, and guaranteed to become a family tradition.

Ingredients  

1x2x3x?

• 3–4 large Ripe tomatoes Sliced thick – salted & drained
• 1 Pie crust Homemade – or store-bought
• ½ teaspoon Coarse salt – For draining tomatoes
• ¼ cup Fresh basil – Torn into pieces
• 1 cup shredded Sharp – cheddar cheese
• 1 cup shredded Mozzarella cheese
• ½ cup Mayonnaise
• 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
• ½ teaspoon Garlic powder – Optional
• ¼ teaspoon Black pepper
• ¼ cup grated Parmesan cheese – Optional topping

Equipment

• 1 9-inch pie pan (Glass or ceramic works best)

• 1 Sharp knife (For slicing tomatoes)

• 1 Cutting board

• 1 Mixing bowl (For cheese mixture)

• 1 Colander/strainer (For draining tomatoes)

• Several Paper towels (To blot excess moisture)

Method 

1. Slice tomatoes ½-inch thick, salt both sides, and let drain on paper towels for 30 minutes, flipping once.

2. Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C), prick the pie crust with a fork, and prebake for 10 minutes. Cool completely.

3. Stir together mayonnaise, mustard, cheddar, mozzarella, garlic powder, and pepper until smooth.

4. Layer half the tomatoes in the crust, scatter basil, spread cheese mixture, then repeat with remaining tomatoes and topping.

5. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 30 minutes until golden. Cool at least 1 hour before slicing.

Nutrition

Serving: 150gCalories: 310kcalCarbohydrates: 20gProtein: 9gFat: 22gSaturated Fat: 7gPolyunsaturated Fat: 3gMonounsaturated Fat: 9gCholesterol: 30mgSodium: 440mgPotassium: 420mgFiber: 2gSugar: 5gVitamin A: 950IUVitamin C: 20mgCalcium: 200mgIron: 1.4mg

Notes

Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.